Maybe it wasn't the wheat. For some, it really is.
Share
A theory behind the Creamy Tuscan Marry Me Chicken.
Here's a theory we can't stop thinking about: maybe wheat, dairy, and carbs were never really the problem. People have eaten them for thousands of years. Maybe it's what we started doing to them.
What Changed
A hundred years ago, a dish like this would've just been pasta, real cream, real butter, and olive oil—full stop. Today, a lot of "modern" versions start differently. Pasta is made from durum wheat, and durum is one of the wheat varieties most likely to be chemically dried right before harvest to speed things up—a practice that's genuinely common in the northern U.S. and Canada, where most durum is grown. That chemical is actually patented as an antimicrobial, and some research suggests it may affect gut bacteria—though this is still an active, unsettled area of research.
Then the cream sauce often gets stretched with thickeners like carrageenan. Multiple studies have linked it to reduced beneficial gut bacteria and increased inflammation markers, though the research is still evolving there too. Add preservatives and cheap, highly processed oils, and it's a pretty different dish than the one your great-grandmother made—even if the name on the menu looks the same.
What We Do Instead
Organic pasta. Real cream and real butter—no stabilizers, no thickeners. Pure extra-virgin olive oil, never industrial seed oils. Fresh sun-dried tomatoes and baby spinach, not jarred substitutes. Nothing here is trying to be a health food. It's just trying to be the dish the way it was made before the shortcuts showed up.
To Be Clear
We're not saying eat rich pasta every night, and we're not saying wheat or dairy are the enemy. We're asking a different question: what if it was never the food itself—just what got done to it along the way?
A Personal Note From Lee
If gluten or dairy don't sit well with you, I'm not dismissing that—those are real, and I dealt with my own struggles with both for years. For a while, that meant sitting at the table eating my own separate dish while my family ate a version of a meal I couldn't touch. It works, but it's not really the point of a meal, is it?
That's a big part of why Hoosier One exists the way it does. I didn't just want to open my own diet back up—I wanted to give my family a cleaner version of the meals they already loved, so we could all eat the same thing again. That's meant leaning on ancient grains like einkorn and dairy like A2 milk wherever we can—though I'll be honest, we're not there on everything yet. Some ingredients, like Parmesan, don't have an A2 option we've found yet. We're still figuring this out as we go, and as we grow, we want to keep expanding how far we can take it.
I want to be upfront: these dishes aren't gluten-free. Einkorn still contains gluten—it's just an older, less hybridized wheat than most of us grew up on. Some people with sensitivities find it easier to tolerate. If you have celiac disease, please keep avoiding gluten entirely—this isn't a substitute for that.
For me, it's been a mix—the relief of opening my diet back up again, and the comfort of knowing I was finally giving my family something both real and a little healthier than what we'd been eating before. There's something to sitting at a table together over a meal that isn't diet food. That's the meal I wanted back for my family. Now I get to give it to yours too.
Our menu rotates weekly, so this dish won't always be available—but there's always something good cooking.